Judge who ruled against sanctuary cities order was an Obama campaign bundler

by Marta Holmes April 27, 2017, 2:20
Judge who ruled against sanctuary cities order was an Obama campaign bundler

In response to the ruling, Trump sent out a flurry of tweets early Wednesday morning criticizing the decision as a "ridiculous ruling" and claiming it was the result of "judge shopping".

Yesterday, U.S. District Judge William Orrick in San Fransisco ruled that the federal government does not have the authority to cut "federal funding that bears no meaningful relationship to immigration enforcement ... merely because a jurisdiction chooses an immigration enforcement strategy of which the President disapproves".

It was the third Trump executive order on immigration to be thwarted by the federal courts.

He said, "They used to call this 'judge shopping!' Messy system".

Then, in March, Trump blasted another federal judge's ruling that blocked a revised version of the travel ban, suggesting it was a politically motivated decision that made the USA look "weak".

The second statement showed the two California governments that sued to block the order - San Francisco and Santa Clara County - had good reason to believe they would be targeted, Orrick said.

In his ruling, Orrick said Trump's January 25 order targeted broad categories of federal funding for the sanctuary cities and that plaintiffs challenging it were likely to succeed in proving it unconstitutional.

Trump tweeted that the 9th circuit, which earlier ruled against his travel ban, has "a awful record of being overturned (close to 80 percent)".

Turkey's premier warns opposition against street protests
Monitors from the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe said the decision undermined important election safeguards. CHP vice chairman Erdal Aksunger said the party expects the board "to eliminate fraud and cancel the referendum".

In February, he called the federal judge in Seattle who ruled against his first travel ban a "so-called judge".

These are cities - among them New York, Los Angeles, Houston, Chicago and San Francisco - that have limited their cooperation with federal immigration authorities.

If Trump is right about the ultimate destination of the sanctuary cities case, he'll face a court reinforced by his own nominee, conservative Justice Neil Gorsuch.

At the same time, the judge said the Justice Department may hold back grant money that is awarded with immigration-related conditions, if those conditions are violated. The appeals court may yet side against him, and the case may end up at the Supreme Court, but it hasn't happened yet.

White House chief of staff Reince Priebus described the ruling as another example of the "9th Circuit going bananas".

Orrick said Trump can not set new conditions on spending approved by Congress.

Orrick is a district court judge and is not part of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, although the latter will hear the Trump administration's appeal. San Francisco and other sanctuary cities say turning local police into immigration officers erodes the trust that is needed to get people to report crime. In the term that ended in 2015, 10 appellate circuits, including the one on which Gorsuch was serving, had reversal rates higher than the 9th Circuit.

Judge Orrick said that the language of the executive order made clear it sought to withhold funds beyond law enforcement.


TOP News

Trump signs executive order requiring review of national monuments
The Antiquities Act of 1906 allows the president to declare federal lands as monuments and restrict how the lands are used. Orrin Hatch, Republicans are urging Congress to withhold money for the national monument in response to the designation.

Active Shooter At Middle School In Mason County
Police said they had a heavy presence heading to the scene of the middle school in Mason County, Washington. The school district quickly confirmed on its Facebook page that there was no active shooter on the campus.

The 4 Russian Federation investigations in Congress, explained
As Trump critics argued at the time, the Senate Intelligence Committee is not set up to do this work. "It was inappropriate. That raised questions about whether the chairman was too close to the White House to lead an impartial inquiry.

Erin Moran's likely cause of death revealed
I'll always choose to remember you on our show making scenes better, getting laughs and lighting up TV screens, ' Howard tweeted . An autopsy and standard toxicology tests were performed on the 56-year-old actress and the results are pending.

Bills Decline To Match Patriots' Offer For Mike Gillislee
This marks the second straight year that the Patriots have plucked a talented player away from Buffalo. ESPN's Adam Schefter reported that it was a done deal and Gillislee was on his way to the Patriots.

McElroy | Adrian Peterson could be very successful with Saints
Speculation regarding free agent running back Adrian Peterson and the Green Bay Packers may soon come to an anticlimactic end. Ingram had his first 1,000-yard season on the ground and racked up a career-high 10 touchdowns for the Saints.

Venezuela threatens to withdraw from OAS
The latest protests began when the pro-government Supreme Court assumed the powers of the opposition-controlled congress. The decision was later reversed amid a storm of global criticism - and from Ortega Diaz herself.

Caitlyn Jenner Considering A Run For Office
She claims to be a Republican despite the staunch and orthodox stand of the party against the LGBT community. I believe in things like the Constitution and limited government. "I ultimately hold him responsible".

Federal judge blocks Arkansas' plan to execute several inmates
Drugmakers have largely objected to having their products used in executions and have refused to sell to prisons for that goal . The state Attorney General's Office said it would seek to have Griffen's order overturn in the state Supreme Court.

National Hockey League playoffs: Sharks' Joe Thornton played with torn ACL, MCL
The Oilers were wary about getting off to a poor start on Saturday after losing to the Sharks 7-0 on Wednesday on their home ice. With McDavid mostly held in check in the series, the outcome was mostly left up to Edmonton's supporting cast.