Justices strike down gender differences in citizenship law

by Marta Holmes June 13, 2017, 7:25
Justices strike down gender differences in citizenship law

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg relied in part on gender equality cases she brought as a pioneering civil rights lawyer Monday as the Supreme Court struck a law that treats unwed mothers and fathers differently when granting citizenship to their children born overseas.

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, writing for the court, noted that the laws dictating citizenship requirements for those born overseas to unmarried parents - found in the Immigration and Nationality Act - "date from an era when the lawbooks of our Nation were rife with overbroad generalizations about the way men and women are".

But in a twist, the ruling failed to provide any relief to Luis Ramon Morales-Santana, the NY resident who successfully challenged the law.

In the interim, she said the law's five-year requirement should apply, prospectively, to children born to unwed USA -citizen mothers.

Popular Video This young teenage singer was shocked when Keith Urban invited her on stage at his concert. Fathers had to meet a longer requirement of physical presence in the USA than did mothers.

In the ruling, the Supreme Court said that until Congress revises the law, both women and men will be covered by the five-year requirement. With two million single fathers now caring for their children in the US, it is high time that this outdated law -rooted in the stereotype that mothers, not fathers, are responsible for their children - is declared unconstitutional. Unwed American mothers, meanwhile, are only subject to a 1-year US residency requirement to give their children USA citizenship. His father, who was unwed when Morales-Santana was born, was 20 days short of satisfying the five-year residency requirement. He challenged the law and asserted he is a USA citizen after authorities sought to deport him following convictions for robbery and attempted murder. But the prospective remedy is that children of unwed mothers have to meet the tougher standard, not that the children of unwed fathers get the more lenient one, she said.

London mayor on Trump tweets: 'I really don't care'
May defended Khan, noting how he has been closely working with her to get the city back on track after a series of deadly attacks. But Mr Khan, who is from Tooting in south London, rejected Mr Trump's proposal for himself to be exempted from the Muslim ban.

Justice Neil Gorsuch was not even nominated when the court heard oral arguments in November, but Monday's decision is otherwise unanimous.

The case is one of several with immigration-related themes that are before the justices at a time when President Donald Trump's administration is pursuing efforts to strengthen immigration enforcement.

"We hold that the gender line Congress drew is incompatible with the requirement that the government accord to all persons 'the equal protection of the laws, '" Ginsburg wrote.

In the interim, she said, the government must ensure the laws are administered in a way that is free from gender-based discrimination.

The court was equally unimpressed with the government's second justification, which centered on a desire to ensure that a child born outside the United States to an unmarried USA -citizen parent would not be "stateless" - that is, lacking any citizenship at all.

When Chief Justice John Roberts announced this morning that Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg was the author of the opinion, it was a good sign for Morales-Santana. And because the court couldn't give Morales-Santana the relief he was looking for, Thomas continued (in a separate opinion that Alito joined), it did not need to decide any other questions, such as whether the residency requirement is constitutional.

Recommended News


TOP News

Trump commits to NATO's Article 5
According to the statement sent to ACTMedia, the American-Romanian Business Council (AMRO) applauds President Donald J. Earlier Mr Trump had his silence on Twitter , tweeting he'd been vindicated and derided Comey as a "leaker".

Murray downs Del Potro, French women feud
He saved a set point at 4-5 and then another in a memorable 10th game, missing a sitter forehand before finally breaking back. Svitolina will next face third-seeded Simona Halep, the French Open runner-up in 2014.

E3 2017: New Life Is Strange Game Officially Revealed, Release Date Announced
One of the best episodic adventure games of the last ten years, Life is unusual , is getting a somewhat surprising prequel. Life is odd prequel was leaked recently so we knew it was coming but didn't know it would be at E3 2017.

Trump commits to NATO mutual defense after hesitating
He did not specifically mention Article 5, which has only been invoked once, after the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks. Iohannis became the third European head of state who Trump received in the Oval Office.

Macron confirms third French victim in London attack
Last night 15 people remained in a critical condition and Australian nurse Kirsty Boden was named as the third fatality. Police and the security agencies are facing questions about whether they missed chances to thwart the attack.

MK Labour Party raise questions over Conservative-DUP deal
The Tories needed 326 seats to win another majority but they fell short and must rely on the DUP to continue to rule. The SDLP and the Ulster Unionists have lost all their Westminster seats.

Warriors' Green will be on the court for this Finals Game 5
Cleveland won games 6 and 7 to cap the greatest comeback in NBA Finals history and dethrone the Warriors . (AP Photo/Tony Dejak). It's like, 'Whoa.' You remember what can be, what can happen".

Watch out OPEC, US could break oil production record of 1970
Industry data on USA oil inventories from the American Petroleum Institute (API) late on May 31 was seen buoying prices. Production fell about 1 million barrels per day over the next year and a half as oil prices collapsed.

White House defends Trump as scathing tweets raise concern
JULIE DAVIS: They are the statements that are the most in Trump's voice of anything we get from this White House . Yet the president's tweets , while informal, do not stick to topics of no effect .

'Wonder Woman' buries 'The Mummy' at box office
Down 51%, the sequel has pocketed $136 million domestically and may finish with $150 million in domestic ticket sales. Obviously, this is news that DC and Warner Bros.is incredibly happy with and suggests a very strong final gross.